I mean I sort of agree with the gist of what you’re saying - privately owned walled gardens invite abuse of power - but using a tautology of “it’s illegitimate because it is” is not a compelling argument.
That’s not quite my argument. I’m not saying “it’s illegitimate because it’s illegitimate,” I’m saying “because it’s illegitimate a priori, it doesn’t even count as a real example of the thing it’s pretending to be.” It’s like saying that drug-dealing doesn’t count as a business model because it’s illegal (where the illegality is treated as a postulate, not a topic of debate).
Also, the point is to be emphatic, not strictly correct. I’m trying to treat it as absurd in order to make people reevaluate their basic assumptions.
“it’s illegitimate because it’s illegitimate,” I’m saying “because it’s illegitimate a priori, it doesn’t even count as a real example of the thing it’s pretending to be.”
You need to show more of your work then, because the argument isn’t making it over the wire intact. How are you defining “platform”, for starters. How does the walled garden stuff invalidate it?
Also, the point is to be emphatic, not strictly correct. I’m trying to treat it as absurd in order to make people reevaluate their basic assumptions.
Sure. But humans being the way they are, when challenged emotionally we stop listening. They’re far less likely to reevaluate their assumptions than to write you off as a crank. I don’t like it but that’s how we are.
So what’s your view on retro gaming? I’m guessing you weren’t even alive in the 80s and 90s when consoles were the primary way you were getting decent games that weren’t made by Sierra.
Aside from the Wii (which I made an exception for because of its unique control scheme and Wii Fit, and also because I was less militant about software freedom in 2007 than I am now), the only consoles I’ve deliberately owned and played* were the SNES, Genesis, and Game Gear.
But even back then, by about 1995 I had already shifted away from Mario and Sonic and towards games like SimCity (which I own for DOS, not SNES), Warcraft, and Myst.
One of the first computer games I owned and played a lot of was Operation Neptune from 1991, BTW.
*
My wife brought a PlayStation and a GameCube with her when we moved in together, and I picked up a SegaCD at some point, but they’ve just sat packed away unused and thus don’t count.
Being a walled-garden makes the platform illegitimate, inherently and by definition. Only open platforms are valid.
Making a walled-garden platform should be a crime.
I mean I sort of agree with the gist of what you’re saying - privately owned walled gardens invite abuse of power - but using a tautology of “it’s illegitimate because it is” is not a compelling argument.
That’s not quite my argument. I’m not saying “it’s illegitimate because it’s illegitimate,” I’m saying “because it’s illegitimate a priori, it doesn’t even count as a real example of the thing it’s pretending to be.” It’s like saying that drug-dealing doesn’t count as a business model because it’s illegal (where the illegality is treated as a postulate, not a topic of debate).
Also, the point is to be emphatic, not strictly correct. I’m trying to treat it as absurd in order to make people reevaluate their basic assumptions.
You need to show more of your work then, because the argument isn’t making it over the wire intact. How are you defining “platform”, for starters. How does the walled garden stuff invalidate it?
Sure. But humans being the way they are, when challenged emotionally we stop listening. They’re far less likely to reevaluate their assumptions than to write you off as a crank. I don’t like it but that’s how we are.
Read this comic about it: https://theoatmeal.com/comics/believe
If you want people to change their mind, you have to get them to trust you. They have to see you as in-group.
And, again, I dislike closed privately owned for profit platforms, so I probably agree with you on a lot of the broad strokes.
This is batshit and I think everything you’re doing is high quality posting
Who the hell is putting “must not be a walled garden” under the definition of “platform”
Me.
So what’s your view on retro gaming? I’m guessing you weren’t even alive in the 80s and 90s when consoles were the primary way you were getting decent games that weren’t made by Sierra.
Aside from the Wii (which I made an exception for because of its unique control scheme and Wii Fit, and also because I was less militant about software freedom in 2007 than I am now), the only consoles I’ve deliberately owned and played* were the SNES, Genesis, and Game Gear.
But even back then, by about 1995 I had already shifted away from Mario and Sonic and towards games like SimCity (which I own for DOS, not SNES), Warcraft, and Myst.
One of the first computer games I owned and played a lot of was Operation Neptune from 1991, BTW.
*
My wife brought a PlayStation and a GameCube with her when we moved in together, and I picked up a SegaCD at some point, but they’ve just sat packed away unused and thus don’t count.
Richard Stallman-ass unpopular opinion, bravo
Whose definition?