• 2 Posts
  • 559 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 5th, 2023

help-circle



  • I think it’s inevitable.
    I also think it won’t be possible on our current kind of computing hardware.

    The software of the human mind, seems a byproduct of the structure of the human brain. I think a major revolution in processor design and manufacturing tech will be needed. It’ll need some fundamentally new form. Closer to an ASIC or FPGA processor to run with any kind of reasonable efficiency. But it’ll have to be truly 3 dimensional, not just layers of 2d chips. It’ll also need to be extremely low power.

    LLMs are as close as we have right now, and they have miles to go. But they need hundreds of times more power than the brain does. No it won’t be soon and it won’t be with this kind of silicon processors.



  • I’m an X-Ray tech at a University hospital with Level 1 trauma. It’s a lot of physical work. A few miles a day of walking, pushing x-ray plates under patients, moving patients to and from the table. It’s also cognitive work, problem solving. Deciding what order to do exams in. Coming up with a way to get the image when the patient can’t move properly. Is this exam even right? Does it make sense? Do we need extra images due to a fracture, or fewer images because the patient says only this part hurts, not the whole arm that was ordered?

    I can say to everyone, any job you can do for 8 hours, you can do 50% longer. It’s surprising.





  • The artificial computer wasn’t so much a scientific breakthrough as a conceptual one. It didn’t require anything that didn’t already exist.

    The quantum computer does exist. And it’s functional principles are built on physics not engineering. It’s a fundamentally different situation.

    If I’d be able to ever collect, I’d bet you $10K in an investment account, that in 10 human generations quantum computers still won’t be portable personal devices.




  • As there have been many scientific breakthroughs to get to where we are now with smartphones.

    That was a long series of inevitable predictable progress in engineering.

    This isn’t a matter of ordinary engineering challenges to be overcome. What I’m talking about is something that upends our understanding of reality. Not just an evolution of what we already know, but a revolution that changes almost everything about our understanding of how the universe works. Discovering new unimagined forms of matter. Things like that.


  • I’m pretty careful with absolute words like that.
    There will need to be some major breakthrough in fundamental physics or material science to get the cooling apparatus much smaller than it is. That’s highly unlikely.

    And quantum computing at higher temps won’t work because the nature if it requires the atoms being measured to have zero resting energy.






  • It was trying to show how Star Wars could grow into more complex storylines than good Jedi vs evil Sith. How the concept of balance the previous films tried to talk about could be reinterpreted as a search for balance within one’s self. Reconciling ones own light and dark aspects makes a whole person. An idea epp 6 started with the turning of Vader at the end.

    Also there was the idea of getting away from the power of dynastic bloodlines. The idea that The Force could choose anyone.

    Finally there was shoehorned in there a message about the inequality in the galaxy, even with the new republic having taken control. There was still the ruling ownership class, and the exploited working class. That part I’ll admit, was very forced and inelegantly tacked on. Should have been saved for the next trilogy.