• brallipop@piefed.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    2 days ago

    I got into Andrea Dworkin after the Contrapoints vid about Anita Bryant. A LOT of Dworkin says is powerful, very hard to deny. She was vehemently against porn, saying that no matter the circumstances, in a patriarchy, the women are definitionally exploited.

    That being said, her arguments just can’t overcome my human biological urges. It is FUN to gamify sex and make it theatrical, kinky. Dworkin is a lot like PETA, I cannot effectively counter the arguments to my own satisfaction, but my body just loves hot kinky sex (and porn) and eating meat too much to give them up.

    • captainlezbian@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      18 hours ago

      I have a ton of respect for Dworkin, but ultimately yeah, I just think she’s very wrong on topics of sex. Especially as someone who’s a leatherdyke and has heard elders stories of conflict with the anti sex 2nd wavers, in my experience a lot of them just don’t really understand wanting all this.

      They see things like feminist porn collectives or people posting nudes online for free the same way someone might see attempts to reduce the harm of a cigarette, but like, some people really need a fucking smoke. And for this, we can’t know if some people are metaphorically wired to be essentially addicted to cigarettes by their innate nature. They get mad at us for wasting all this effort instead of just outright banning them. Meanwhile we look at them frustrated and confused because banning them won’t work, will backfire politically, and isn’t necessary if we can make a harmless cigarette. And yeah, terrible analogy, but my point is hopefully kinda clear

      • brallipop@piefed.zip
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        12 hours ago

        Lol, no that’s great, it’s exactly my point! So hard to make an argument against sex-negativity that is really cogent. But in the end, my body and mind don’t yearn for cogent arguments, so they don’t matter anyway (at least for this particular topic).

        • captainlezbian@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          edit-2
          8 hours ago

          I’ve got a clearer head now than earlier lol. To a certain degree, yeah, but I do think there’s a pretty firm argument by counterexample. I’ve met bdsm practitioners who are feminist radicals who have no willingness to engage in any sexual or kink exchanges with men. This was a major player in this discussion in the 80s actually as the lesbian feminist bdsm collective Samois was regularly fighting this culture war within the feminist and lesbian spheres. The anti porn response is that we’re recreating these dynamics that we’ve learned from patriarchy within the confines of our orientations and ideologies, but if we’re arguing like that, the sex positive response is that where we’re recreating the whore, they’re recreating the Madonna. Patriarchy has also had a long history of mandating sexual purity in women and a firm opposition to sexual play similarly looks like a trauma response to patriarchy.

          Fundamentally, I’m a pretty loud defender of feminism within the bdsm community and I’ve looked for reasons why women seem largely to prefer submission to dominance and to work to resolve problematic reasons there. For example, one of the big ones is that dominant women’s boundaries keep being pushed to the point many dommes leave the community and many switches (to a certain degree myself included, though I leaned pretty submissive and it’s hard to see what I’d want without those bad experiences among other issues) move towards being submissive.

          Edit: recreating the whore, not the whole